PART 6 – An Afternoon of Cinnamon Rolls Brought Back Memories We Had Never Discussed

Ben arrived on the last Saturday in January carrying a notebook.

He wanted the cinnamon-roll recipe written down.

“I want to make them myself one day,” he said.

I showed him the faded index card Paul had kept in a tin beside the flour.

The measurements were smudged.

There was a little grease stain beside the word butter.

“Grandpa wrote that?”

“Yes. He kept changing the recipe because he never believed he'd got it quite right.”

Ben smiled.

“Sounds like Dad when he cooks burgers.”

I let him measure the flour.

He read every instruction aloud before he touched anything.

Sam would have plunged both hands into the bowl.

Ben preferred knowing where he was going.

Ben had asked to arrive early so we could check the ingredients together.

He stood beside the pantry with a pencil behind one ear.

“Did Grandpa always weigh the flour?”

“No. He measured it in cups and insisted he could tell when the dough felt right.”

“Can you?”

“Usually.”

“That doesn't help me write the recipe.”

I found my small kitchen scale.

We measured the flour by weight and wrote the number beside Paul's original instruction.

Ben was pleased.

“Now if I make it at home, it should work.”

“It will still depend on the room temperature and the flour.”

He frowned.

“That's annoying.”

“Most useful skills are.”

He was patient while the yeast foamed.

When nothing appeared to happen for the first two minutes, he asked whether we'd ruined it.

I told him to give it time.

He sat on a stool and watched the bowl.

“What if it doesn't rise?”

“Then we try again.”

He looked at me thoughtfully.

“You don't always say that when something goes wrong.”

I knew what he meant.

For years, I'd treated problems at Christmas as emergencies.

I had hurried to replace ruined dishes and rearrange seats before anyone saw a mistake.

“I'm trying to learn,” I said.

He nodded solemnly.

Then the yeast began to bubble.

“It's alive,” he said.

“Very much so.”

We both leaned closer to watch.

While the dough rose, I made us sandwiches.

He asked about Paul's life before he became a grandfather.

I told him about the hardware store where we had first met.

I had gone in to buy screws for a crooked kitchen cabinet.

Paul had spent twenty minutes showing me three ways to repair it.

He had given me the wrong screws.

I went back the next day.

“On purpose?” Ben asked.

“I never found out.”

Ben laughed.

Then he asked whether Paul had ever fought with me.

“Of course.”

“About what?”

“Money. Time. The thermostat. Your mother, sometimes.”

That caught his attention.

“Mom?”

“When she was young, we disagreed about rules. Like every family.”

“Did Grandpa yell?”

“Sometimes. He wasn't perfect.”

I did not want to turn Paul into a saint whose memory the living had to compete with.

He had been loving and stubborn, patient with children and occasionally impossible with adults.

He had apologized badly at first.

Then he had learned to do better.

“Once,” I told Ben, “he promised Karen he'd attend her school concert. He missed it because he stayed late at work.”

“What happened?”

“She refused to speak to him for two days.”

“Did he buy her something?”

“No. He asked her to tell him why it mattered. Then he attended the next three concerts.”

Ben considered that.

“Dad missed my game last month.”

“Did you tell him you were upset?”

“He said he had a meeting.”

“That could be true.”

“I know. I just wish he'd said he was sorry.”

I nodded.

“Maybe tell him that part.”

Ben picked at the edge of his sandwich.

“Everyone keeps telling me to be understanding.”

“Understanding doesn't mean pretending you're never disappointed.”

He looked relieved.

When the timer rang, we punched down the dough.

I stood back while he rolled it out.

The rectangle had one corner much thicker than the other.

“It's terrible,” he said.

“It's bread. It doesn't have to pass a geometry exam.”

He laughed and kept working.

We spread the filling and rolled it into a long uneven cylinder.

I showed him how to cut the pieces with a length of clean kitchen thread.

He tried it twice.

The second roll came apart in his hands.

He looked frustrated.

I told him to place it in the pan anyway.

When the rolls baked, they rose against one another until the gaps disappeared.

“See?” I said.

“They're all different.”

“And all edible.”

We had time for another batch after the first pan went into the oven.

Ben wanted to see whether adding a little orange zest changed the flavor.

Paul had sometimes done that when there were oranges left from Christmas stockings.

We washed one and grated the skin carefully.

I made Ben smell the zest before adding it.

He closed his eyes.

“That smells like Christmas.”

“That's why I like it.”

He wrote an optional note in his notebook.

Then he insisted on labeling the pans so he could taste the difference fairly.

I admired his seriousness.

When the rolls came out, we waited until they were cool enough not to burn our mouths.

He chose the plain one first.

Then the orange one.

He chewed slowly.

“The orange one is better,” he announced.

“Your grandfather would have agreed.”

“Then we should keep that version.”

“We can keep both.”

He considered that.

“Right. People might like different things.”

I smiled.

It was a reasonable conclusion for a baking experiment.

It was also a useful thought for a family that had spent too long arguing over a single right way to celebrate.

While they cooled, Ben opened his notebook.

There were two pages of questions about Paul.

What was his favorite song?

Had he ever traveled overseas?

Why did he keep a pocketknife on his key ring?

I answered what I could.

For the questions I couldn't answer, I said so.

Ben asked to see the photograph of his grandfather that stood beside the kitchen clock.

I took it down carefully.

Paul was sitting on a park bench wearing a ridiculous straw hat.

Ben had been four at the time.

He remembered the hat but not the day.

I told him it had been a picnic after an unusually rainy summer.

Paul had bought strawberries from a roadside stand and insisted everyone eat them before the clouds returned.

Ben traced the edge of the frame.

“Is it weird that I don't remember his voice very well?”

“No,” I said. “You were young.”

“I remember his laugh.”

“So do I.”

I told him we had an old recording of Paul reading a story to Lucy.

I had saved it on a small drive and copied it to my computer.

“Can I hear it?”

“Of course.”

We listened to a minute of Paul's voice.

Ben smiled and then grew very quiet.

I let the recording end without saying anything.

After a while he asked whether he could have a copy.

I said I would ask Karen to help me send it.

His eyes filled, but he didn't look away.

“Thanks, Grandma.”

I squeezed his shoulder.

There were things a recipe could preserve.

There were other things worth keeping too.

At the bottom of the second page was a different question.

Why do adults act like saying sorry means they lost?*

I sat beside him.

“That's a hard one.”

“I wrote it after Christmas.”

I thought about all the ways we had avoided saying simple things.

Karen had avoided telling me she wanted a different holiday.

Ted had avoided telling his mother she had been rude.

I had avoided calling Karen before mailing letters that referred to a visit.

And the children had decided to act rather than ask again.

“Sometimes we mistake being right for being safe,” I told him.

He frowned.

“What does that mean?”

“We think if we admit a mistake, somebody else gets to decide everything.”

“But they don't.”

“No. They don't.”

He wrote the sentence down.

I wished I had learned it at his age.

Near the end of the afternoon, Ben asked whether it was all right to bring a roll to Arthur.

“Of course,” I answered.

“I thought you might be mad at him.”

“I was hurt by his comments last year.”

“That's different?”

“Yes. I can dislike something he said and still want him to enjoy a cinnamon roll.”

Ben nodded.

“Dad says Grandma Diane makes really good biscuits.”

“Then perhaps she'll teach you those too.”

He looked pleased by the idea.

I was pleased myself.

A child with two sets of grandparents should not have to rank them like contestants.

I helped Ben wrap the rolls in paper, then showed him how to write the date on the bag.

He added a note in his careful handwriting.

Made by Ben, with Grandma Ruth helping.*

I wanted to correct the order of the names.

Then I decided he had earned the first position.

When Karen came to collect him, the house smelled of cinnamon.

He carried a paper bag containing six rolls.

“Dad gets one,” he said.

“Of course.”

“Even if he says they're too sweet.”

“Then he can have half.”

Karen smiled.

On the porch, she noticed the old recipe card still on the counter.

“I used to make those with Dad,” she said.

“You did.”

“He always gave me the scraps.”

“He told me that was because you were the official taste tester.”

“I believed him.”

I looked at her.

“He meant it.”

She touched the card with one finger.

“Sometimes I feel like if we change Christmas, we're getting rid of him.”

The admission surprised me.

I had believed the traditions comforted her.

Perhaps sometimes they also made her feel trapped.

“Paul would never have wanted you exhausted on his account,” I said.

She smiled sadly.

“He'd have made the coffee and told everyone to stop arguing.”

“He might have.”

Karen folded the card carefully and gave it back.

“Can I copy this?”

“Take a picture.”

She did.

Then she stood at the door for another moment.

“Maybe next Christmas we could make these together instead of you doing everything.”

“Maybe,” I answered.

I did not turn the possibility into a promise.

There were eleven months before another Christmas.

We had ordinary Saturdays to get through first.


Click here to continue reading: PART 7: When I Stopped Hosting Every Occasion, I Discovered What I Actually Missed

Story Parts

The Christmas Message That Turned Forty-One Years of Tradition Into a Question

Part 6 of 12

Previous: Part 5
Next: Part 7